I would take the 2 piece option as I enjoy a challenge!
As it was Blue Peters 50th birthday here you go Dave.
Tools required:-
Super fine draughtsman's pen
Super sharp craft knife
Leather punch or similar
The top piece can be made using your current Proporta protector as a template and I don't think it would muffle the sound that much covering the speaker hole, try a piece of Sellotape over it and see! If it is a problem then it is only straight cuts after marking out neatly.
The bottom piece shouldn't be that difficult, the trick I think is to cut the hole first allowing enough protector over each side for trimming down each side. I would cut the hole out using a leather punch or visit your local saddlery/shoe repairer etc.
Next time it is the Advent candle holder made out of coathangers.
__________________
Windows Phone Specialist certification
Windows Phone Expert certification
Windows Phone Business certification
O2 HTC HD2, O2 Xda Guide, O2 Ignito, O2 Orbit 2, Acer beTouch E100, Acer M900, Acer DX900, Glofiish V900.