Hi Eddie I have had no such problem here, I still use the battery and once it charges the HD2 it cuts out, but once the HD2 is low on charge I can plug the battery back in and charge until full again, So I don't have the problem your having.
__________________
Windows Phone Specialist certification
Windows Phone Expert certification
Windows Phone Business certification
O2 HTC HD2, O2 Xda Guide, O2 Ignito, O2 Orbit 2, Acer beTouch E100, Acer M900, Acer DX900, Glofiish V900.