4WinMobile.com

Go Back   4WinMobile.com > 4WM Reviews > 4WM Reviews - Software

4WM Reviews - Software The latest Pocket PC / Smartphone Software reviews on 4WinMobile. This forum will be used for posting or announcing software reviews of Pocket PC / Smartphone related products.

Post New Review Comment
 
Review Tools Search this Review Display Modes
Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review
Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review
Published by firstbuddha
04-03-2008
Author review
Overall Design
100%100%100%
10.0
Speed
90%90%90%
9.0
Usability
100%100%100%
10.0
Interface
100%100%100%
10.0
Value for money
90%90%90%
9.0
Graphics
100%100%100%
10.0
Stability
100%100%100%
10.0
Functionality
100%100%100%
10.0
Help and Instructions
100%100%100%
10.0
Flexibility/Customisation
60%60%60%
6.0
Upgrades and Support
90%90%90%
9.0
Average 94%
Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

Image
Introduction

Spb Mobile Shell 1.0 was first introduced during 3GSM last year. The software proved to be a clear hit, outperforming all other Windows Mobile applications on the market and coming out as the best-selling Pocket PC program of the year.

But with the dawn of the iPhone the user is now more aware of "the look" being almost as important as functionality. Spb Mobile Shell is aiming to target people who need the power of a Windows Mobile device, but are not happy with the standard Pocket PC user interface.

For those of you who may not have experienced Spb Mobile Shell, I recommend you read the (SPB Mobile Shell 1.0)4WinMobile Reviews

With many new changes implemented into Spb Mobile Shell 2.0, is it really worth putting yet another app onto our devices?

Read on and make up your own mind...

Supplier Spb Software House
Product Spb Mobile Shell 2.0
Cost $29.95 (15 day full-feature trial available) see below for upgrade pricing
Supported OS WM5 PPC or later
Supplier Web Site Spb Software House
Product Web Site Spb Mobile Shell

4WinMobile would like to thank Yaroslav Goncharov of Spb Software House for providing a copy of Mobile Shell for review purposes.



Image







Today Plug-in

With this latest release of Mobile Shell, the familar Today plug-in is retained, offering the following functionality:
  • Dynamic icon showing battery status
  • Most Recently Used items list, with ability to "pin" favourite items
  • Dynamic clock with world times and access to native alarm application
  • Dynamic weather icon with detailed weather data for the week ahead
  • Photo speed dial for quick-calling your favourite contacts
Image
That GLORIOUS Now Screen

The Now screen is still available with two different styles.
The "Classic" Now screen and the "Professional" Now screen.
The main differences being the visible calendar and additional phone profile functionality of the "Professional" Now screen.

The Now screen is displayed when turning on the device (and can be changed in the options).

Ask yourself, when you turn on your device what are you wanting to do?
For me, it is usually one of the following:
  • Check the time
  • Check when my next appointment is
  • Check if I have any new messages/email
  • Check if I have any missed calls/voicemail
  • Call a contact
  • Run an application
Mobile Shell lets you do all the above with ease. The Now screen is an un-cluttered easy to read screen with all the information that I would require "right now". The Today screen can be for "today" or even "next week", but the Now screen shows me a quick snapshot of the status of the device.

Staying at the Now screen, I am able to see the time and date, current weather, my current phone profile (silent, normal, etc), see my next alarm, next appointment and the calendar. I can also see indicators for new mail, messages and missed calls.

The new Now screen has separate screen views for weather - by pressing the weather icon with my finger a full screen weather panel shows the current weather and the weather for the rest of the day. This full screen weather panel also shows the weather for the remainder of the week for my selected location. The weather is configurable by city but it doesn't appear that templates can be used. The weather source used is unknown.

Pressing the clock also launches a new panel for the clock. This displays the time and date for the selected location along with world times of selected cities and the status of the native alarm application. The native alarm application can also be launched from this clock panel.

On first use, the cities for weather and time are selected and are synchronised with the Spb servers. You can choose to synchronise the weather automatically or manually.

Constantly, however, I was finding myself returning back to the Spb Menu to run the default Comm Manager app, as there is no plugin to control the Bluetooth, WiFi, or other radio options. I find throughout the day, that I change the status of both Bluetooth and WiFi quite a lot, so it was disappointing to find this wasn't possible from the Now screen.

Users who have Spb Phone Suite can change Phone Suite profiles from the "Professional" Now screen.

It would be nice to be able to re-arrange the items on the Now screen, choosing where to place the items that I use most. If I wanted to swap the clock position with the weather icon this is currently not possible. But with a choice of "Professional" or "Classic" Now screen, I believe that Spb have managed to satisfy the user's requirements.

But the good news is you don't have to put your hand in your pocket if you only require a basic phone profile changer as you can choose simple phone profiles from the Now screen. With a choice of normal, silent or vibrate, it is easy to change these profiles swiftly.

All this functionality is possible with a finger - without having to remove the stylus!

ImageImageImage







ImageImage




Spb Menu

The phone style menu of Spb Menu still exists. In addition to its finger friendly layout of icons, the most recently used list of applications from the Today plug-in is also visible on this screen.

To access the Spb Menu from the Now screen, simply press the second large icon at the bottom, or use a gesture (see later section).

This list is a copy of the icons from the Today plug-in. As well as most recently used, you can also "pin" your favourite applications to this list so that you have direct access to your favourite applications.

The Spb Menu is configurable, so you can choose which applications you want easy access to. Sadly, there isn't a way to remove the most recently used list from the top of the Spb Menu, so only 6 of the original 8 icons for Spb Menu are ever visible. It is a shame that this wasn't implemented for Mobile Shell 2.0 as Spb Menu was one of my favourite features of Mobile Shell 1.5.

However, the confirguration options for Spb Menu are still very limited. I would prefer to have a fully configurable Spb Menu, where I can choose to add on this screen whatever I choose and remove those items that I do not want. Sadly, this isn't currently possible.













ImageImageImagePhoto Speed Dial

Pressing the third icon at the bottom of the Now screen shows the Photo Speed Dial panel.
Here you can assign up to 24 speed dials for your favourite contacts. A great finger friendly screen to easily call my contacts without having to remove the stylus.
You can substitute one of these contact squares for the Spb Contacts application. Those that have used previous versions of Mobile Shell will recognise this as the "T9" style quick search for contacts.

However, it gets better. Pressing one of your favourite contacts brings up the contact screen. With a photo of your contact, and the available contact details (such as home, work, mobile, send sms, etc). This is a fantastic panel for easily getting in touch with your favourite contacts, still without removing the stylus. I wish there was a way to integrate this with Spb Contacts, so this screen is displayed for all contacts on my device, not just through the Photo Speed Dial contacts.








Gestures and Transition Animations

ImageImageImageImage

So far I have described how Spb have crafted Mobile Shell to be a great looking and functional application.
What we haven't covered yet is navigating around the new Spb Now/Menu/Contacts panels.

It is possible to navigate around the three main panels using the large buttons at the bottom of the Now screen (Now, Launcher, Contacts and exit).
'The hardware softkeys (if your device has these) can be used to navigate the three panels. The fun and quick way to navigate is with the finger! Simply "swiping" the screen horizontally will change to the next panel. All the transition effects can be changed using the options within Mobile Shell settings and animations can be disabled for faster transitions.

Within the Spb Menu launcher pane (second pane), all the sub-menus are navigable with finger swipes also. See... still no need for a stylus!!

Now back to Now... this all-in-one application is great for launching apps, making calls and setting the current status of the device. But what if I'm already in an application and I want to run Now? I could turn off the device and turn it back on again (this would bring up my Now screen), or I can return to the Today screen and launch Spb Menu from the softkey; but Spb have thought of a better way to initiate the application. In an application (such as Pocket Word), if I drag my finger from the Windows Start flag (top left) to the centre left of the screen, and HOLD it there I will see three stacked panes on the screen. These are the different panes of Now, Spb Menu and Spb Contacts. Now moving my finger across the screen I can choose which of these panes I want to see.

Spb should perhaps highlight how to run this gesture as soon as this app is installed. From first installing this application onto my device, it took me a while to realise how to execute the gesture.

It's little features like the gesture to start Now that really show Spb have thought about how the user interacts with their device. The native button mapper can be set to map the Now screen to a hardware key, but with the gesture to launch the panels it makes life that little bit easier - and still, no stylus


Image



Memory Usage and Performance

A concern from a lot of users of new applications from Spb has been performance on the device, not least the RAM consumption.

For those readers who like to compare numbers, the chart shown here displays how Spb have managed to add animation and more graphically-rich features to Mobile Shell and DECREASE the amount of program memory in use!

From using the application compared to previous versions of Mobile Shell, I haven't experienced the "lag" that other users have encountered with the original Mobile Shell.













Price and Upgrade Policy

The price has not been changed between versions. Spb Mobile Shell 2.0 will be available from the Spb website for $29.95.

If you are a Spb Mobile Shell 1.x owner, you can upgrade to 2.0 for 50% off the retail price. If you purchased the previous version within 90 days from the release date, you are entitled to a free upgrade.

More details regarding Spb Software House's upgrade policy are available here



Product Data

Product version 2.0
Installer size (cab) 3.24 MB
Supported languages English, German, Italian, French, Spanish, Portugese, Russian, Traditional Chinese, Simplified Chinese, Japanese, Polish, Czech, Dutch,
Registration type 14 day fully-feature trial
Release Date 4th March 2008
Supported OS Windows Mobile 5.0 for Pocket PC and later
Size in ROM (qVGA) 3.39 MB
Size in ROM (VGA) 4.41 MB
RAM consumption (qVGA) 1.24 MB
RAM consumption (VGA) 2.48 MB




Pros

Finger-friendly user interface = reduced stylus use
Dynamic icons for the Today plug-in
Multi-tabbed Now screen, to allow quick access to status screens
Reduced RAM consumption
Program launcher, status screen and photo dialler all in one application
Beautiful and clear graphics
Animation effects for transition between the panels
Integration with other Spb applications
Upgrade policy provides discounts for current users of Mobile Shell 1.x

Cons
Limited customisation of the Spb Menu remains
Unable to disable "radio" profiles from Now screen (such as WiFi, Bluetooth, etc)
Unable to re-arrange items on the Now screen



4WM Rating 94%



Conclusion

Spb Mobile Shell 2.0 builds upon the finger-friendliness of the original Mobile Shell application. For me, it remains the first application that I install on my device (even before my backup application). Spb have identified where Microsoft should have improved upon the operating system to make devices not only functional and easy to use, but also graphically beautiful.
With this latest release, the memory issues appear to have been addressed by the developers. With the new transition animations, I can show off my device with pride to friends and family for that truly wonderful "oooh" WOW factor.
Whilst customisation of areas such as the Spb Menu launcher and the Now screen is still restrictive, this is an application that should appease both new or basic Windows Mobile users and power/professional users alike. Power users will appreciate the integration of Mobile Shell into the core of the operating system and basic users will feel that they can finally unlock the potential of their device with easy navigable menus and beautiful rich graphics.
Put away your stylus, gesture with your finger and start living "Now".
  #1  
By waveydavey on 04-03-2008, 08:25 AM
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

Cracking review Chris, and well done SpB. I liked the original Mobile Shell in theory but it just wasn't something I could use every day. MS2 just about has it all. I agree I'd like to be able to customise the Now screen a bit more but it just about does the trick. The only thing I'd have to disagree with is the SpB menu graphics. I like the layout but the icons are a bit "Fisher Price" for my liking. Still, I've not seen my today screen for a while!
Reply With Quote
  #2  
By saki on 04-03-2008, 10:02 AM
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

I have just tried this and i must say I am mightily impressed. Its slick in operation and well thought out. The acid test is whether or not it is significantly better than any similar software (including the original HTC software). In my view it is a significant improvement upon anything else I have tried. Excellent review by the way firstbuddha !

Who needs a cube when you can have a well-rounded Shell?
Reply With Quote
  #3  
By firstbuddha on 04-03-2008, 10:18 AM
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

Now all the documentation is available (like the FULL user manual), I've read that if you have Spb Weather or Traveller, then the Now screen can use that as your weather source.
This means you can use the BBC templates, for exmaple

Also, if you have Spb Time installed, then you can use Time as your default alarm application from within the Mobile Shell time panel.
Reply With Quote
  #4  
By boz on 04-03-2008, 10:26 AM
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

Great review Chris, even more so in the given timescale!
Reply With Quote
  #5  
By torford on 04-03-2008, 11:04 AM
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

Great review and good looking software, but with the Orbit 2 I have the HTC touch stuff and I also run pocket plus with weather, time and diary...so do I need it?

Decisions, decisions!
Reply With Quote
  #6  
By waveydavey on 04-03-2008, 11:17 AM
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

I know exactly what you're saying. For me personally the improved contacts screen where you can select to easily dial different numbers and send a text are excellent and I love the Now screen.
Reply With Quote
  #7  
By windows on 04-03-2008, 05:55 PM
Member reviews
Overall Design
90%90%90%
9
Speed
100%100%100%
10
Usability
80%80%80%
8
Interface
100%100%100%
10
Value for money
80%80%80%
8
Graphics
100%100%100%
10
Stability
90%90%90%
9
Functionality
80%80%80%
8
Help and Instructions
80%80%80%
8
Flexibility/Customisation
60%60%60%
6
Upgrades and Support
90%90%90%
9
Average 86%
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

Very impessed with it myself, been using it for the past week, and it is still on my machine which says a lot for it. It works beautifully on the Orbit 2 and is a dream to use.

I wish it has an animated new mail indicator, and a bit more flexibility, but top notch. Well done Spb!
Last edited by windows; 04-03-2008 at 05:58 PM.
Reply With Quote
  #8  
By Michael_Mcr on 04-03-2008, 06:55 PM
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

I currently have an Orbit 2 with Pocket Plus 4 and Pocket Breeze as a plug-in on its own Pocket Plus Tab. This combination gives me pretty much what i want - Whatever tabs / shortcuts / plug-ins i want on one screen and a 30 day diary with 1 tap and a glance. Anything else is pretty much only one Tab-tap away.

I Installed Mobile Shell 2 (trial) this morning and have spent some time playing with it. It is very quick and impressive - especially the speed of the screen flips. It is obvious that a lot of thought has gone into it.

However... I am very frustrated by the inability to customise the Now screen. For instance, i would hope to be able to tap the calender display and launch pocket breeze - instead it opens the boggy WM6 calender and i cant see a way to change this. (maybe SPB Diary would integrate here ?, but i prefer Pocket Breeze)

The lack of GPRS / 3G traffic indicator on the taskbar is also a bit worrying - i have an unlimited Data bundle, but even so i want to be able to see when an app is deciding to connect.

The other major stumbling block for me is the lack of customisation flexibility available for the Tabs in the Mobile Shell Today Plug-in - with a few more options, i could use it as a replacement for Pocket Plus - but not as it currently stands.

There is hope in the fact it is a new product (and a mightily impressive one at that) with the facility to embrace third-party plugs-ins when they appear, but for now i am uninstalling it and going back to Pocket Plus.

Regards

Michael
Reply With Quote
  #9  
By Enlli on 04-03-2008, 07:42 PM
Member reviews
Overall Design
80%80%80%
8
Speed
80%80%80%
8
Usability
60%60%60%
6
Interface
60%60%60%
6
Value for money
80%80%80%
8
Graphics
80%80%80%
8
Stability
50%50%50%
5
Functionality
60%60%60%
6
Help and Instructions
50%50%50%
5
Flexibility/Customisation
50%50%50%
5
Upgrades and Support
70%70%70%
7
Average 65%
Re: Spb Mobile Shell 2.0: Review

I have to agree with Michael_Mcr with regards to the calendar in the Now screen. Not being able to have the calendar of your choice is a bit of a bind.

I agree too with not having any way of looking at data traffic. With the standard bar I could see what was happening in if I was standard 2G, 3G or HSDPA.

Two problems for me are: 1) its insistence to wake up in the Today Screen despite having the Now screen selected. 2) Not being able to run pocket breeze from one of the tabs on the Today Screen as the who thing just seems to draw gibberish and seize up.
Reply With Quote
Post New Review Comment  

Bookmarks
Review Tools Search this Review
Search this Review:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:19 AM.

Sponsors


 


Design by: vBulletin Skins Zone
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Relevant URLs by vBSEO 3.2.0
(c) Daron Brewood - www.4winmobile.com 2004-2008

Review powered by GARS 2.1.8m ©2005-2006Ad Management by RedTyger